Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliner & Buying Guide [2021]

Michelle Robinson

Eyeliner is the most versatile type of makeup accessory, and the right type will complement the look you want to achieve.

To find the right one that will bring that smoky eye look or liquid look, you have to be aware of the different types that are available on the market.

The following are the best cruelty-free eyeliners available today. They are vegan and have no animal ingredients in their formulas.

Top Cruelty-Free Free Eyeliner Compared

Product ImageProduct NameFeaturePrice
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner - Best Waterproof
  • Matte finish
  • Waterproof
  • Price: $8.97
24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil - Best Glider
  • Easy To Apply
  • Does not run
  • Price: $22
KVD Vegan Beauty Tattoo Eyeliner - Best Liquid Eyeliner
  • A high-pigment, vegan, waterproof
  • This product is vegan and cruelty-free
  • Price: $27.5
Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner - Best Micro Fine Tip
  • Soft smudger tip
  • Available in multiple colors
  • Price: $4.84
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Matte Liquid Eyeliner
  • Includes precision brush
  • Liquid eyeliner
  • Price: $5.94
COVERGIRL Ink It By Perfect Point Plus Waterproof Eyeliner
  • Gel-like, smooth-glide formula that won't budge
  • Long-lasting, fade-resistant formula
  • Price: $5.94
Milani Infinite Liquid Eyeliner
  • Infinite Liquid Eyeliner creates an elastic film that lines the eyes without smudging or smearing, for up to 24 hours
  • Available in one rich, black color
  • Price: $11.53
Physicians Formula Eye Booster Lash 2-in-1 Boosting Eyeliner & Serum
  • Deep brown
  • Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Price: $8.74
VASANTI Kajal Waterline Eyeliner - Best for Sensitive Eyes
  • So intense looks similar to a liquid eyeliner with ease of application of a pencil
  • Waterproof and smurge proof
  • Price: $19
Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner
  • Hypoallergenic & Ophthalmologist tested
  • Its inky-black, high-impact formula glides on seamlessly to create a perfect-looking, satiny smooth line that stays put for up to 8 hours
  • Price: $9.99
Beauty For Real I-Line 24-7 Eyeliner
  • No sharpener required
  • Safe for sensitive eyes
  • Price: $14
Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner
  • Gluten-free liquid eyeliner
  • Features a fine calligraphy tip
  • Price: $15.6
Marcelle Waterproof Eyeliner
  • Metal green
  • Ultraprecise tip helps create a range of looks from a precision cat eye design to a softer, dramatic smoky eye
  • Price: $13
Better Than Sex Easy Glide Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
  • Free of parabens and phthalates
  • Created to produce a sharp, fluid, smudge-proof line every time
  • Price: $29
E.L.F. Cosmetics Kohl Eyeliner
  • Dual-ended soft pencil shades
  • A built-in sharpener cap for convenient sharpening
  • Price: $7.95

Reviews of Best Cruelty-Free Free Eyeliner Today

1. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner – Best WATERPROOF

This is an intensely segmented waterproof and smudge-proof eyeliner. It helps you achieve precise and black liquid lines. The tip of the brush is slender and flexible.

What Are Buyers Saying?

It is waterproof and long-lasting, and it is easy to work with.

Why Buyers Love It

This product ranges from fine and natural to broad and bold. Every stroke is liquid and can be controlled for a perfect finish. It is waterproof and pigments very well.

Price: $8.97

Buy on Amazon

2. 24/7 Glide-On Eyeliner Pencil – Best Glider

This is a richly pigmented and creamy eyeliner that glides on smoothly. It is soft, easy to blend, and gives a long-lasting finish that does not budge.

What Are Buyers Saying?

I love it so much; it is long-lasting and waterproof and designed for all-day wear. It is super simple to use and removes quickly at the end of the day.

Why Buyers Love It

It has many shades to accommodate different people. Plus, it has moisturizing ingredients, such as jojoba and vitamin E.

Price: $22.00

Buy on Ulta

3. KVD Vegan Beauty Tattoo Eyeliner – Best Liquid Eyeliner

This is a vegan liquid and waterproof eyeliner that has a precise brush tip. This brush allows for easy application, creates extra-thin lines, and brings out the best cat-eyes and wings.

What Are Buyers Saying?

This is a must-have eyeliner. It is long-lasting and easy to apply. It also stays all day without smudging. I advise you to store it upside down to prevent it from drying up.

Why Buyers Love It

It is easy to create that cat-eye or winged eye. The super-fine tip allows for easy application and maneuvering. It is also long-lasting.

Price: $27.50

Buy on Sephora

4. Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner – Best Micro-fine Tip

This product has a fine point that glides on easily, offering a precise line. It also has a smudge tip that brings out a smokier or softer look. It has a sharpener and is available in many colors.

What Are Buyers Saying?

This option has many shades that can be chosen from to match your look. Plus, it comes with a sharpener, which is just perfect.

Why Buyers Love It

The colors are perfect and so soft. It is also easy to apply. It is of high quality and has an affordable price.

Price: $4.84

Buy on Amazon

5. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Matte Liquid Eyeliner

This liquid eyeliner enables one to have a bold and classic look. It also has a perfect thin brush tip that allows maximum control while drawing thick or thin lines.

What Are Buyers Saying?

It is so perfect, and the matte liquid liner does not dry up. The thin brush allows an easy application and makes me look great.

Why Buyers Love It

It is affordable and long-lasting. Your cat eyes can last for days without smudging.

Price: $5.94

Buy on Amazon

6. COVERGIRL Ink It By Perfect Point Plus Waterproof Eyeliner

It is a gel-like, smooth-glide formula that won’t budge. It brings out well-defined eyes that last all day.

What Are Buyers Saying?

I like this eyeliner more than any other that I have used. It stays on very well and wipes off without much effort at the end of the day. It rolls on very nicely.

Why Buyers Love It

It can be easily removed with soap and water. It is also self-sharpening. Therefore, one can maneuver around and bring out a perfect line.

Price: $5.94

Buy on Amazon

7. Milani Infinite Liquid Eyeliner

It is an incredibly long-wearing formula that is waterproof and semi-permanent. It brings out an elastic film that lines the eye without smudging and smearing. It is available in one rich, black color.

What Are Buyers Saying?

I highly recommend infinite eyeliner. The brush is perfect and brings out precise lines. The formula also remains until you wash it off.

Why Buyers Love It

It stays all day, and there is no need to apply it every time.

Price: $11.53

Buy on Amazon

8. Physicians Formula Eye Booster Lash 2-in-1 Boosting Eyeliner & Serum

It is a high-tech eyeliner and serum that delivers a high precision pigment liquid eyeliner while also nourishing the eyelashes. It is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

What Are Buyers Saying?

This eyeliner and serum work very well. It goes on easy, not too thick or thin, and helps grow your eyelashes.

Why Buyers Love It

While giving you a smoky look, it also grows your eyelashes. It is light and easy to use. It is also nourishing for an everyday look.

Price: $8.74

Buy on Amazon

9. VASANTI Kajal Waterline Eyeliner – Best For Sensitive Eyes

This product is good for sensitive eyes, and it gives comfort without compromising how long you can wear it. It is safe for delicate eyes and is also water-resistant and smudge-proof.

What Are Buyers Saying?

It is so amazing, and it gives a naturally defined look that makes lashes appear longer and fuller. There is no irritation, and it is safe for delicate areas.

Why Buyers Love It

It glides on well, does not irritate, and does not smudge or smear.

Price: $19.00

Buy on Amazon

10. Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner

This eyeliner is an inky black high formula that glides on well and creates a perfect and satin-smooth look. It lasts longer, and it does not smudge or smear.

What Are Buyers Saying?

It does not flake or smudge on me. The formula and brush are great and work so well.This eyeliner not only works amazingly but does not cause any issues for my skin!

Why Buyers Love It

This eyeliner doesn’t smudge and has perfect liquidity. Since it is not waterproof, it can be removed easily. The brush has a perfect thickness.

Price:$9.99

Buy on Amazon

11. Beauty For Real I-Line 24-7 Eyeliner

This type of eyeliner is suitable for all activities, whether working out or swimming. It will last longer without smudging due to the waterproof gel-like formula that is highly pigmented and waterproof.

What Are Buyers Saying?

I loved it. It has a very smooth liner that glides on very well. I loved the color, and it’s easy to use. I highly recommend it.

Why Buyers Love It

This eyeliner is a deep, rich, black color. It is long-lasting and doesn’t smear or smudge. Also, it is easy to apply, and it doesn’t need to be sharpened before use

Price:$14.00

Buy on Amazon

12. Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner

This is a gluten-free liquid eyeliner that features a fine calligraphy tip. It is formulated with jojoba oil, which allows for smooth and easy application. It also keeps the skin around the eye hydrated.

What Are Buyers Saying?

It is a great product. The brush is firm and easy to use. It stays on when I cry when my eyes water or when I’m working out.

Why Buyers Love it

This is an excellent eyeliner. It goes on smoothly, the color is nice, and the brush isn’t too flimsy.

Price:$15.60

Buy on Amazon

13. Marcelle Waterproof Eyeliner

This eyeliner is hypoallergenic and fragrance-free. It has a creamy formula that allows you to create a precise line and a smudged finish. It can be easily removed with any makeup remover.

What Are Buyers Saying?

I highly recommend this to anyone who is allergic to makeup. I normally can’t wear eye makeup due to severe allergies, but I was able to wear this and had no irritation.

Why Buyers Love It

It is easy to apply and can be sharpened. It is also affordable and does not cause any irritation.

Price: $13.00

Buy on Amazon

14. Better Than Sex Easy Glide Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

This is the easiest cutting edge liquid eyeliner to use. It brings out a smooth, smudge-proof fluid line. The bush fibers and black formula uniquely make it an easy and precise eyeliner.

What Are Buyers Saying?

It is very precise and lasts throughout my day. It also allows a darkly pigmented color without having to apply so many times.

Why Buyers Love It

It is so easy to do winged liner (thick or thin). This product is perfect for people wanting to learn to do liner because it is so easy to glide.

Price:$29.00

Buy on Sephora

15. e.l.f. Cosmetics Kohl Eyeliner

This eyeliner contains a soft gel-like formula that is easy to blend and build, and it brings out a smoky eye look. Its dual-ended pencil has a sharpener cap for sharpening and a sponge tip for blending.

What Are Buyers Saying?

This eyeliner pencil has a built-in sharpener, which is great and works well. The other end has an applicator for smudging. It is an amazing product that is easy to use.

Why Buyers Love It

It is cost-efficient, glides smoothly, and is long-lasting.

Price:$7.95

Buy on Amazon

Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliner Buying Guide

Eye makeup is so essential whether you are a makeup person or prefer a natural look. Many outlets have a lot of different eyeliners with different formulas and ingredients.

Depending on your preferences or needs, there are plenty of options to choose from.

Cruelty-free and vegan products are the best since you can apply your eye makeup knowing that the brand does not test or using animal products.

It is better to understand what you are looking for in an eyeliner than to make the best value for your money. Things to look at might include:

Type Of Shade

Many shades can be chosen from. Most females prefer black. Choose a shade that compliments the type of outfit or the occasion.

Style Of Your Eyeliner

Style varies depending on how you apply your eyeliner. There are different styles to choose from, such as smoky, winged, cat-eye, dramatic, or normal.

For a normal look, use eyeliners that are less pigmented. If you are opting for a smoky or cat-eye look, use liquid eyeliner.

Type Of Finish

The types of finish include a glossy look, a matte look, or a liquid look. You should decide the type of look that suits you and choose the right eyeliner.

FAQs

Are cruelty-free eyeliners safe to use?

Most brands that make cruelty-free products conduct extensive research and scientific experiments with evidence that narrows down the ingredients. They also conduct test experiments to ensure it is safe to be used.

Which is the best eyeliner to use?

Pencil eyeliner is the best to use. It is not messy, and it glides easily into the eyes.

How can I put my eyeliner on so that it doesn’t smudge?

First of all, wash your face properly before applying the eyeliner. Then, moisturize it along with a primer. Apply concealer in the under-eye area. After this, apply the eyeliner.

Summary

The above eyeliners are the best cruelty-free mascara options available on the market right now. It is important to understand that there are different types of eyeliner. The types mentioned above will guide you toward your preferences.

Leave a Comment